top of page

Which Eagles Team Would Win: All-Time 1st Rounder vs. All-Time 2nd Rounders?

With the NFL draft right around the corner, we are taking a look back through Eagles drafts of years past.

Through the 89 year history of the team there have been enough quality early picks to create Pro Bowl caliber starting 11s. So it begs the question -- which group of all-time Eagles is better: 1st round picks or 2nd round picks?

Here's a breakdown of the two starting squads:

1st Round Team

QB: Donovan McNabb

RBs: Steve Van Buren

WRs: Mike Quick, Jeremy Maclin, DeVonta Smith

TEs: Keith Jackson

OLs: (T) Bob Brown, (G) Shawn Andrews, (C) Jermane Mayberry, (G) Jerry Sisemore, (T) Lane Johnson,

DLs: (DE) Brandon Graham, (DT) Fletcher Cox, (DT) Jerome Brown, (DE) Mike Mamula

LBs: Chuck Bednarik, Jerry Robinson, Tim Rossovich

CBs: Lito Sheppard, Roynell Young

S: Brian Dawkins, Wes Hopkins

Bench: FB Clarance Peaks, WR Kenny Jackson, FB Keith Byars, TE Charle Young, T Tra Thomas, DT Corey Simon, DT Mike Patterson, LB Steve Zabel, DE Richard Harris

2nd Round Team

QB: Randall Cunningham

RBs: LeSean McCoy

WRs: DeSean Jackson, Jordan Matthews

TEs: Zach Ertz, Dallas Goedert

OLs: (T) Barrett Brooks, (G) Landon Dickerson, (C) Guy Morriss, (G) Bobbie Williams, (T) Winston Justice

DLs: (DE) Vinny Curry, (DT) Gary Pettigrew, (DT) Trevor Laws, (DE) Victor Abiamiri

LBs: Michael Kendricks, Maxie Baughan

CBs: Eric Allen, Bobby Taylor, Sheldon Brown

S: Brian Dawkins, Wes Hopkins

Bench: S Michael Lewis, QB Jalen Hurts, RB Miles Sanders, S Nate Allen, WR Reggie Brown, TE L.J. Smith, RB Charlie Garner, RB Billy Ray Barnes, QB Jack Concannon

So who would win? Take a vote in our Twitter poll!


Stay up to date!  

Thanks for submitting!